The newest documentary from Netflix, Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare, is the extremely disturbing true story of emotional manipulation and deceit over more than a decade. Based on the real-life catfishing case that left listeners stunned when it was first shared on the Sweet Bobby podcast, the film brings this twisted tale to the screen. While the film does shock with its jaw-dropping revelations, there also needs to be some narrative flaws worked out.

A Tale of Deception A deceitful catfishing scam in this novel paralyzes the life of Kirat Assi, a Radio presenter living in London. Ten years later, Kirat falls for a man she believed was Bobby-persuasively charming and warm. What she does not realize is that Bobby is not real-that he is a creature made by somebody much closer to her than she could ever imagine. While it doesn’t give away the whole twist for new viewers, Bobby’s real identity is a horrifically brutal betrayal in how it crosses over between love, friendship, and obsession. The extend of manipulation combined with Kirat’s emotional suffering prompts a struggle over the depth of cruelty human beings can be so capable of.

Flaws: Unbelievable Manipulation, Lack of Complexity in Relationships

The documentary aptly succeeds in portraying the psychological impact that catfishing can cause in a victim. Kirat’s candid interviews reveal a glimpse of how such long-term emotional torture can be inflicted with betrayal. Viewers are drawn into her vulnerability, and by that, the eventual revelation of truth only makes it sadder.

The documentary educates people on how social media and online relationships make one vulnerable to the catfishing scam. Above all, it gives a warning story for any individual navigating their way in relationships in the world of social media.

Flaws: Pacing Issues and Gaps in the Story

While Sweet Bobby is a grueling rollercoaster of emotions, however, the documentary is far from perfect. In spots it drags on too much, and in others compresses crucial details with too much haste. Implicated aspects of investigation and reasoning behind manipulator’s motives are not left well-explored, giving viewers too many questions that remain unanswered.

There has also been some criticism of the documentary in that it did not dig deeper into certain aspects that can be presented from either a legal or psychological point of view. Viewers who would like to see stronger investigative work or a commentary by some authority on the matter might find the documentary somewhat structurally unsatisfying as compared to some other true crime series, at least for Netflix.

While the film does shock emotionally and has a resonance with it, it could have used a much deeper dive into the implications that have to do with wider web deceit. Matters of reality where and when it blurs with virtual personas, or how and why the catfishes manage to continue catfishing for so many years were mentioned but never carried all the way through. It reads more like a retelling of Kirat’s personal journey than a more comprehensive study of the phenomenon.

Final Verdict

*Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare* is far from a perfect documentary, but it is so gripping. This film takes you into the world of lies, manipulation, and betrayal; that in itself is enough reason to watch this movie. The shocking twists make some of its viewers crave more depth and clarity; however, that is what makes Sweet Bobby good because it tends to happen to anyone so easily-to-outsmart, yet hard to mend after it happens.

Sweet Bobby is a gripping, if flawed, trek into the dark side of online relationships, just perfect for true-crime and personal-documentary fans. Shocking, with all the intimacy of a deep secret shared by the person sitting next to you on the bus – only not in the end, despite all your many questions.

Image Source