A Day of Reflection, but is it Enough?

Every November 11, Canadians take a moment to acknowledge a debt of gratitude to those who served and sacrificed. What started in 1919 to mark the anniversary of the armistice that ended World War I has materialized into what is now called Remembrance Day, highly meaningful throughout Canada, citizens on this day come together to remember veterans, lay wreaths, and observe two minutes of silence.

But as decades turn into generations, some ask whether a single day does justice to the memory of those who fought. With fewer Second World War and First World War veterans alive, for most Canadians any personal link with that history is gone. Does Canada remember them enough?

Origins: From Armistice to Remembrance Day

Remembrance Day in Canada was born out of the massive impact brought about by World War I. It was a brutal war, which claimed over 60,000 lives of Canadians. Hundreds of thousands of families were left in tears; communities across Canada sorrowed. Known as Armistice Day, the observance first marked the end of that war, celebrated on the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month. This tradition has continued to this very day by maintaining two minutes of silence with regard to the fallen.

In 1931, the day was officially renamed in Canada to Remembrance Day-to remember those lost not just in the First World War but lost in all later conflicts. This eventually brought in the red poppy as the official symbol of remembrance because of the poem In Flanders Fields. They would be worn in memory of the sacrifices that were made by Canadian soldiers.

Remembrance Day Observation in Canada

Canada has Remembrance Day ceremonies throughout the country. The largest gathering is at the National War Memorial in Ottawa, where the Governor General, government officials, members of the military, and civilians attend. Most towns and cities hold their own events, which are usually attended by veterans, serving members, and civilians who gather to remember.

Schools also join in teaching young Canadians about Remembrance Day by telling stories, reading poems, and holding discussions on what the day really means. To some critics, it is too ceremonial and has little substance or significance for children who have never lived through a war.

“Young people need more than a history lesson,” insists Sarah Johnson, a veteran advocate. “They need to know why we remember.

Is the connection of Canada to Remembrance Day fading?

As the years go by, fewer Canadians have any direct links to the world wars. As the years go by and the veterans of World War II get older and die, there’s a growing concern that eventually Remembrance Day will indeed be far removed. There’s an increasing feeling of detachment in Remembrance Day, particularly among younger Canadians who see events from the point of view of a history lesson instead of personal.

Schools still have classes on Remembrance Day, yet there’s a sense that some teachers struggle to connect the experience of these days to students. Perhaps in response, groups like the Royal Canadian Legion and the Canadian War Museum have designed programs to put veterans in classrooms to tell their stories directly to kids. But still there seems to be a disconnect:.

Seeing the day as just a day off work or school risks losing its meaning,” says historian Mark Davies. “Canada needs to keep this history alive in ways that are relevant today.”

Beyond the Poppy: Are Symbols Enough?

Wearing a red poppy has become the most recognizable way Canadians show respect on Remembrance Day. Inspired by the resilient flowers that grew on battlefields in World War I, the poppy symbolizes sacrifice and resiliency. But for some, wearing just a poppy does not suffice when it comes to paying our due respect to veterans.

Veterans groups urge Canadians to think in terms of more tangible practices. It is remembrance that should transcend into actual support for veterans’ welfare instead of a symbolic one at ceremonies. Issues related to mental health care, housing, and financial aid for veterans are just some of the lines where the support has fallen short in recent years.

A Call for More Practical Support to Veterans

For many veterans, the fight doesn’t end with the battle. Mental health issues, financial instability, and a lack of health care underscore the lives of so many former service members. According to advocacy groups, the support given by Canada to veterans is simply not enough, adding long waiting times for medical services along with scarce resources for those suffering from PTSD and other mental health issues.

Many feel that remembering the dead involves tending to the living. Wounded Warriors Canada and Veterans Affairs Canada do vital work in this respect but often without the resources necessary to address the needs of all veterans.

“Honouring veterans must include a commitment to their wellbeing,” said Mike Rogers, a WWII veteran and activist. “Otherwise, Remembrance Day becomes just words and rituals.”

Remembrance Day Modern Relevance

The Canadian military has changed; it has participated in UN peacekeeping, and in more recent times, operations in Afghanistan. To the younger generation of veterans, Remembrance Day is still important; however, they would like to see the day reflect what their service has been like in present day. They feel that recognition of veterans needs to go beyond historic battles to the most current issues faced today by active service members.

In 2014, Canada instituted the National Day of Honour to commemorate Canadian soldiers’ sacrifices in Afghanistan. While many people applauded the day, others claim that one day was not enough to show appreciation for today’s veterans. Proponents argue that all veterans need more constant care and publicity campaigns. The publicity campaigns help keep the conscience of Canadians attuned to the continuing needs of veterans.

Critics Ask: Does One Day Tell It All?

Of course, not everyone is a fan of Remembrance Day. To some, one day of ceremonies and rituals is simply not enough to commemorate the losses for so many. They believe that what Canada requires is an approach that infuses the spirit of Remembrance Day into its activities throughout the year.

Veterans and advocates offer ideas that include public education about what military life is really like, mental health programs for veterans, and community support programs. Schools could work in the cost of war and peaceful ways throughout the year, rather than just on one day.

True remembrance requires us to carry these values daily, not just once a year,” said Mary Chen, a peace educator. “If we only honour them once a year, the past will eventually fade away.”

Conclusion: A Remembrance Day in Evolution for Future Generations

It finds a deep niche in Canadian history, thoroughly devoted to men and women who lost their lives for the sake of peace. Times change, however, and with them, the ways in which we remember change. Canada stands at a crossroads: whether to move forward with one observance held every year or to try to make stories and contributions of its veterans alive in the public mind through expanded efforts.

Whether it be from better, more informed education, more support for veterans, or making remembrance a year-round affair, there are paths to take in further entrenching Remembrance Day’s legacy into the core of Canadian society. We do it to ensure future generations appreciate sacrifice, the cost of freedom, and support those who have served.

In the end, it is not just about remembering but remembering with a purpose. Remembrance Day needs to transcend tradition for an everyday commitment to the honoring of veterans through actions and respect.

image source